How many times can a Belleville washer be used?

Mechanical joint secured by a threaded fastener

If you are looking for more details, kindly visit HEGONG SPRING.

Bolted joint in vertical cutaway

Stud joint, where a headless threaded rod is screwed into a tapped housing and then secured with a nut

Screw joint

A bolted joint is one of the most common elements in construction and machine design. It consists of a male threaded fastener (e. g., a bolt) that captures and joins other parts, secured with a matching female screw thread. There are two main types of bolted joint designs: tension joints and shear joints.

The selection of the components in a threaded joint is a complex process. Careful consideration is given to many factors such as temperature, corrosion, vibration, fatigue, and initial preload.[1]

Joint types

[

edit

]

Tension joint

[

edit

]

There are two types of tension joint: non-preloaded and preloaded.[2]

Non-preloaded tension joint

[

edit

]

These joints are not tightened to a precise preload, and the tension is mainly used to keep parts together without generating a high clamping force. An applied tensile load may cause separation of the joint. This type of joint should not be used where it is frequently subjected to variations of tensile loading.[2]

Preloaded tension joint

[

edit

]

In these joints, the bolt is tightened to apply a specific preload, generating a tensile force in the bolt and an equal compressive force in the clamped parts. This ensures that any applied tensile loads are distributed between the bolt and the clamped parts (see theory section), which has some advantages:

• For cyclical tension loads, the bolt does not experience the full amplitude of the load, which increases its fatigue life. If the material has an endurance limit, the fastener's life may extend indefinitely.

  [

  3

  ]

• The bolt remains secure without the relative movement that could cause loosening, potentially eliminating the need for additional locking mechanisms.

The joint should be designed so that the preload always exceeds the external tensile load to prevent separation. If the external tensile load exceeds the preload, the joint will separate, allowing relative motion between the components, potential bolt loosening, and increased load on it.

In both the preloaded tension and slip-resistant shear joints, some level of preload in the bolt and resulting compression in the clamped components is essential to the joint integrity. The preload target can be achieved by a variety of methods: applying a measured torque to the bolt, measuring bolt extension, heating to expand the bolt then turning the nut down, torquing the bolt to the yield point, testing ultrasonically, or by applying a certain number of degrees of relative rotation of the threaded components. Each method has a range of uncertainties associated with it, some of which are very substantial.[4]

Shear joint

[

edit

]

There are two types of shear joint: slip-resistant and the bearing type.[2]

Slip-resistant shear joint

[

edit

]

The bolt is tightened to a specified preload in these joints. This preload generates friction between the clamped parts, allowing shear loads to be transferred through the joint faces via friction, rather than being carried directly by the bolt. Relative motion between the clamped parts is prevented and thus any fretting wear that could result in the development of fatigue cracks. Any tensile loads applied to these joints, usually have a secondary effect, but they do reduce the effective preload.

The relative stiffness of the bolt and the connected parts is less critical in calculating preload for a slip-critical joint compared to a preloaded tension joint (see theory section). Methods of applying preload are described in the preloaded tension joint section.

Bearing type shear joint

[

edit

]

These joints are not tightened to a precise preload, and the tension is mainly used to keep parts together without generating a high clamping force. In this type of joint, the shear load is transmitted through bearing contact between the bolt and the walls of the bolt holes in the connected parts. When a shear load is applied, the connected parts move and the bolt shank makes contact with the hole walls, which transfers the load from the parts to the bolt. This causes a shear stress in the bolt at the junction of the connected parts, which it resists through its shear strength. As bearing type joints rely on this direct contact, they are more susceptible to wear and deformation of the bolt holes under high or repeated loads, which can lead to bolt fatigue or elongation of the holes over time. Any tensile loads applied to these joints, usually have a secondary effect, but they can reduce available shear strength of the bolt.

A clevis linkage, which relies on a locking mechanism (like lock washers, thread adhesives, and lock nuts), is a bearing type shear joint.

Theory

[

edit

]

Key concepts

[

edit

]

Typically, a bolt is tensioned (preloaded) by the application of a torque to either the bolt head or the nut. The applied torque causes the bolt to "climb" the thread causing a tensioning of the bolt and an equivalent compression in the components being fastened by the bolt. The preload developed in a bolt is due to the applied torque and is a function of the bolt diameter, the geometry of the threads, and the coefficients of friction that exist in the threads and under the torqued bolt head or nut. The stiffness of the components clamped by the bolt has no relation to the preload that is developed by the torque. The relative stiffness of the bolt and the clamped joint components do, however, determine the fraction of the external tension load that the bolt will carry and that in turn determines preload needed to prevent joint separation and by that means to reduce the range of stress the bolt experiences as the tension load is repeatedly applied. This determines the durability of the bolt when subjected to repeated tension loads. Maintaining a sufficient joint preload also prevents relative slippage of the joint components that would produce fretting wear that could result in a fatigue failure of those parts.

The clamp load, also called preload of a fastener, is created when a torque is applied, and so develops a tensile preload that is generally a substantial percentage of the fastener's proof strength. Fasteners are manufactured to various standards that define, among other things, their strength. Torque charts are available to specify the required torque for a given fastener based on its property class (fineness of manufacture and fit) and grade (tensile strength).

Spring Analogy for a Bolted Joint

When a fastener is tightened, a tension preload is develops in the bolt, while an equal compressive preload forms in the clamped parts. This system can be modeled as a spring-like assembly, where the clamped parts experience compressive strain, and the bolt tensile strain. When an external tensile load is applied, it reduces the compressive strain in the clamped parts and increases the tensile strain in the bolt. The load carried by the bolt and the clamped parts is in proportion to their stiffness because they both experience the same induced strain. As a result, the external load is shared across the joint rather than being solely carried by the bolt. In a well-designed joint, about 10-20% of the applied tensile load is carried by the bolt with the greater part transferred through the clamped parts because they are much stiffer than it. This reduction in the proportion of load transferred to the bolt is important in applications with cyclic loading, as bolts have low fatigue strength due to the stress concentration in their threads.[5]

In some applications, joints are designed so that the fastener eventually fails before more expensive components. In this case, replacing an existing fastener with a higher strength fastener can result in equipment damage. Thus, it is generally good practice to replace old fasteners with new fasteners of the same grade.

Formulas

[

edit

]

The force in the bolt of a joint, which has not separated, is[6] F b = F p + C ' F e {\displaystyle F_{b}=F_{p}+C\cdot F_{e}} and in the clamped parts F c = ' F p + ( 1 ' C ) ' F e {\displaystyle F_{c}=-F_{p}+(1-C)\cdot F_{e}} where

F e {\displaystyle F_{e}} is the external applied force, and

F p {\textstyle F_{p}} is the bolt preload.

The portion of an external load carried by the bolt is the joint stiffness ratio C = k b / ( k b + k c ) {\displaystyle C=k_{b}/(k_{b}+k_{c})} where

k b {\textstyle k_{b}} is the stiffness of the bolt,

k c {\displaystyle k_{c}} is the stiffness of the clamped parts

Separation of the clamped parts occurs when the force at the clamped surfaces is zero ( F c = 0 {\textstyle F_{c}=0} ) thus the separation force is F e c = F p / ( 1 ' C ) {\displaystyle F_{ec}=F_{p}/(1-C)} Separation under the bolt head occurs when the force in the bolt is zero ( F b = 0 ) {\displaystyle (F_{b}=0)} thus the separation force is, F e b = ' F p / C {\displaystyle F_{eb}=-F_{p}/C}

Bolt Joint Stiffness Ratio and Load Sharing

The accompanying graph and table illustrate how the relative stiffness of the clamped parts and the bolt affects the portion of applied load carried by it. For example, when the stiffness of the clamped parts equals that of the bolt (the blue curve), an external load in the range from minus to plus twice the preload results in only 50% of the applied load being transferred to the bolt, as the total load in the bolt only varies by twice the preload. If the tensile applied load exceeds twice the preload, the clamped parts separate, and the bolt carries the entire load. Conversely, if the compressive load is lower than twice the preload, separation at the bolt head occurs, and the force in the bolt is zero. The curve representing a clamped parts-to-bolt stiffness ratio of 0.01 shows that when the relative stiffness of the clamped parts is very low, almost all of the load is transferred to the bolt, down to the point where a compressive load equals the preload, and separation at the bolt head occurs, reducing the force in the bolt to zero.

Effect of Bolt to Clamped Parts Stiffness Ratio Clamped Parts Stiffness
Bolt Stiffness

( k c / k b ) {\displaystyle (k_{c}/k_{b})}

Joint

Stiffness

Ratio

( C {\displaystyle (C} = k b / ( k b + k c ) ) {\displaystyle =k_{b}/(k_{b}+k_{c}))}

Portion of
Applied Load
Transferred
to Bolt

( = C ) {\displaystyle (=C)}

Range of Joint Integrity
Applied Load
Bolt Preload Separation
at Bolt Head

( ' 1 / C ) {\displaystyle (-1/C)}

Separation of
Clamped Parts

( 1 / ( 1 ' C ) ) {\displaystyle (1/(1-C))}

0.01 0.99 99 % -1.0 100 0.5 0.67 66 % -1.5 3.0 1.0 0.50 50 % -2.0 2.0 3.0 0.25 25 % -4.0 1.3

Calculating the torque

[

edit

]

Engineered joints require the torque to be chosen to provide the correct tension preload. Applying the torque to fasteners is commonly achieved using a torque wrench.[7] The required torque value for a particular fastener application may be quoted in the published standard document, defined by the manufacturer or calculated. The side of the threaded fastening having the least friction should receive torque while the other side is counter-held or otherwise prevented from turning.

A common relationship used to calculate the torque for a desired preload takes into account the thread geometry and friction in the threads and under the bolt head or nut. The following assumes standard ISO or National Standard bolts and threads are used:

T = K P p r e d {\displaystyle T=KP_{pre}d}

where

T {\displaystyle T}

K {\displaystyle K}

P p r e {\displaystyle P_{pre}}

d {\displaystyle d}

The nut factor K accounts for the thread geometry, friction, pitch. When ISO and Unified National Standard threads are used the nut factor is:[8]

K = d m 2 d ( tan ' ψ + μ sec ' α 1 ' μ tan ' ψ sec ' α ) + 0.625 μ c {\displaystyle K={\frac {d_{m}}{2d}}\,\left({\frac {\tan \psi +\mu \sec \alpha }{1-\mu \tan \psi \sec \alpha }}\right)+0.625\mu _{c}}

where

d m {\displaystyle d_{m}}

d {\displaystyle d}

tan ' ψ {\displaystyle \tan \psi }

(thread pitch)/(pi * dm)

Thread Pitch = 1/N where N is the number of threads per inch or mm

μ {\displaystyle \mu }

α {\displaystyle \alpha }

μ c {\displaystyle \mu _{c}}

When μ {\displaystyle \mu } = μ c {\displaystyle \mu _{c}} = 0.15, the dimensions used correspond to any size coarse or fine bolt, and the nut factor is K ' 0.20, the torque/preload relationship becomes:

T = 0.20 P p r e d {\displaystyle T=0.20P_{pre}d}

A study of the effect of torquing two samples, one lubricated and the other unlubricated, 1/2 in.- 20 UNF bolts to 800 lb-in, produced the same mean preload of  lbf. The preloads for the unlubricated bolt sample had a standard deviation from the mean value of  lbf, whereas the lubricated sample had a standard deviation of 680 lbf. If the preload value and torques are used in the above relation to solve for the nut factor it is found to be K = 0.208, which is very close to the recommended value of 0.20 [8]

Accuracy of Bolt Preload Based on Bolt Preload Method

[

9

]

Method Accuracy Torque wrench on unlubricated bolts ± 35% Torque wrench on cad plated bolts ± 30% Torque wrench on lubricated bolts ± 25% Preload indicating washer ± 10% Computer-controlled wrench (below yield) ± 15% Computer-controlled wrench (yield sensing) ± 8% Bolt Elongation ± 5% Strain Gauges ± 1% Ultrasonic Monitoring ± 1%

The preferred bolt preload for structural applications should be at least 75% of the fastener's proof load[7] for the higher strength fasteners and as high as 90% of the proof load for permanent fasteners. To achieve the benefits of the preloading, the clamping force must be higher than the joint separation load. For some joints, multiple fasteners are required to secure the joint; these are all hand tightened before the final torque is applied to ensure an even joint seating.

The preload achieved by torquing a bolt is caused by the part of the torque that is effective. Friction in the threads and under the nut or bolt head uses up some fraction of the applied torque. Much of the torque applied is lost overcoming friction under the torqued bolt head or nut (50%) and in the threads (40%). The remaining 10% of the applied torque does useful work in stretching the bolt and providing the preload. Initially, as the torque is applied, it must overcome static friction under the head of the bolt or nut (depending on which end is being torqued) and also in the threads. Finally, dynamic friction prevails and the torque is distributed in a 50/40/10 % manner as the bolt is tensioned. The torque value is dependent on the friction produced in the threads and under the torqued bolt head or nut and the fastened material or washer if used. This friction can be affected by the application of a lubricant or any plating (e.g. cadmium or zinc) applied to the threads, and the fastener's standard defines whether the torque value is for dry or lubricated threading, as lubrication can reduce the torque value by 15% to 25%; lubricating a fastener designed to be torqued dry could over-tighten it, which may damage threading or stretch the fastener beyond its elastic limit, thereby reducing its clamping ability.

Either the bolt head or the nut can be torqued. If one has a larger bearing area or coefficient of friction it will require more torque to provide the same target preload.[10] Fasteners should only be torqued if they are fitted in clearance holes.

Torque wrenches do not give a direct measurement of the preload in the bolt.

More accurate methods for determining the preload rely on defining or measuring the screw extension from the nut. Alternatively, measurement of the angular rotation of the nut can serve as the basis for defining screw extension based on the fastener's thread pitch.[11] Measuring the screw extension directly allows the clamping force to be very accurately calculated. This can be achieved using a dial test indicator, reading deflection at the fastener tail, using a strain gauge, or ultrasonic length measurement.

Bolt preload can also be controlled by torquing the bolt to the point of yielding. Under some circumstances, a skilled operator can feel the drop off of the work required to turn the torque wrench as the material of the bolt begins to yield. At that point the bolt has a preload determined by the bolt area and the yield strength of the bolt material. This technique can be more accurately executed by specially built machines. Because this method only works for very high preloads and requires comparatively expensive tooling, it is only commonly used for specific applications, primarily in high performance engines.[12][13]

There is no (as yet) simple method to measure the tension of a fastener in situ. All methods, from the least to most accurate, involve first relaxing the fastener, then applying force to it and quantifying the resultant amount of elongation achieved. This is known as 're-torqueing' or 're-tensioning' depending on which technology is employed.

Technologies employed in this process can be:

An electronic torque wrench is used on the fastener in question, so that the torque applied can be measured as it is increased in magnitude.

Recent technological developments have enabled tensions to be established (± 1%) by using ultrasonic testing. This provides the same accuracy to that of strain gauging without having to set strain gauges on each fastener.

Another method that indicates tension (mainly in erecting steel) involves the use of crush-washers. These are washers that have been drilled and filled with orange RTV. When a given force has been applied (± 10%), orange rubber strands appear.

Large-volume users (such as auto makers) frequently use computer-controlled nut drivers. With such machines, the computer is in control of shutting off the torque mechanism when a predetermined value has been reached. Such machines are often used to fit and tighten wheel nuts on an assembly line, and have also been developed for use in mobile plant tire fitting bays on mine sites.

Thread engagement

[

Contact us to discuss your requirements of belleville disc. Our experienced sales team can help you identify the options that best suit your needs.

edit

]

Thread engagement is the length or number of threads that are engaged between the screw and the female threads. Bolted joints are designed so that the bolt shank fails in tension before the threads fail in shear, but for this to hold true, a minimum thread engagement must be achieved. The following equation defines this minimum thread engagement: [14]

L e = 2 × A t 0.5 π ( D ' 0. p ) {\displaystyle L_{e}={\frac {2\times A_{t}}{0.5\pi \left(D-0.p\right)}}}

Where Le is the thread engagement length, At is the tensile stress area, D is the major diameter of the screw, and p is the pitch. This equation only holds true if the screw and female thread materials are the same. If they are not the same, then the following equations can be used to determine the additional thread length that is required:[14]

J = tensile strength of external thread material tensile strength of internal thread material {\displaystyle J={\frac {\text{tensile strength of external thread material}}{\text{tensile strength of internal thread material}}}}

L e 2 = J × L e {\displaystyle L_{e2}=J\times L_{e}}

Where Le2 is the new required thread engagement.

While these formulas give absolute minimum thread engagement, many industries specify that bolted connections be at least fully engaged. For instance, the FAA has determined that in general cases, at least one thread must be protruding from any bolted connection. [1]

Failure modes

[

edit

]

When doing a failure mode analysis for bolts that have broken, come loose or corroded, careful consideration must be given to the below failure modes:

Overloading

Overloading occurs when operating forces of the application produce loads that exceed the clamp load, causing the joint to loosen over time or fail catastrophically.

Over-torquing

Over-torquing might cause failure by damaging the threads and deforming the fastener, though this can happen over a very long time. Under-torquing can cause failures by allowing a joint to come loose, and it may also allow the joint to flex and thus fail under fatigue.

Fatigue

When axial or transverse loading overcomes the bolts preload or causes the bolt to slip transversely, movement in the bolt can cause small cracks to build up in the material eventually leading to fatigue failure of the bolt or male threaded component. According to Bill Eccles from boltscience, [In the vast majority of applications, the most effective way to ensure that the bolt is fatigue resistant is to ensure that it is tightened sufficiently...]

[

15

]

Brinelling

Brinelling may occur with poor quality washers, leading to a loss of clamp load and subsequent fatigue failure of the joint.

Other failure modes

Other modes of failure include corrosion, embedment, and exceeding the shear stress limit.

Bolted joints may be used intentionally as sacrificial parts, which are intended to fail before other parts, as in a shear pin.

Locking mechanisms

[

edit

]

Bolted joints in an automobile wheel. Here the outer fasteners are four studs with three of the four nuts that secure the wheel. The central nut (with locking cover and cotter pin) secures the wheel bearing to the spindle.

Locking mechanisms keep bolted joints from coming loose. They are required when vibration or joint movement will cause loss of clamp load and joint failure, and in equipment where the security of bolted joints is essential. A prevalent test for the self-loosening behaviour is the Junker test.

Jam nuts

Two nuts, tightened on each other. In this application a thinner nut should be placed adjacent to the joint, and a thicker nut tightened onto it. The thicker nut applies more force to the joint, first relieving the force on the threads of the thinner nut and then applying a force in the opposite direction. In this way the thicker nut presses tightly on the side of the threads away from the joint, while the thinner nut presses on the side of the threads nearest the joint, tightly locking the two nuts against the threads in both directions.

[

16

]

Prevailing torque nuts (locknuts)

An insert on the internal threads (either metallic or non-metallic, e.g. Nyloc nut) or a plug/patch of non-metallic material on the external threads is installed. This material binds against the threads of the opposing fastener with a friction force and creates a prevailing torque, which resists the backing-out or loosening of the fastener.

[

17

]

Chemical locking compounds (thread-locking fluid)

The use of a chemical locking compound binds the threads together when the compound cures. Examples of such a compound includes anaerobic compounds such as Loctite, which cures in the absence of oxygen and acts as an adhesive to lock the threads of the joint together.

[

17

]

Chemical locking methods create friction after the breakaway torque. The prevail torque is usually higher than zero since the cured polymer still creates friction when rotating the nut.[

citation needed

]

Safety wire (lockwire)

Holes are drilled in nuts and bolt heads, and wire is threaded through the holes to prevent back-rotation. This method of locking is labor intensive, but is still used on critical joints.

[

1

]

Locknuts

Some portion of the nut deforms elastically during tightening to provide a locking action.

Spring washers and lock washers

A washer that bends axially during tightening. Spring washers create additional axial force whereas lock washers have parts that engage the surfaces in a way to provide more direct resistance against rotation.

Bolt banging

[

edit

]

Bolt banging occurs in buildings when bolted joints slip into "bearing under load", thus causing a loud and potentially frightening noise resembling a rifle shot that is not, however, of structural significance and does not pose any threat to occupants.

A bolted joint between two elements may act as a bearing-type joint, or a friction joint. In the friction joint, the elements are clamped together with enough force that the resultant friction between the clamped surfaces prevents them from slipping laterally over each other.

In the bearing joint, the bolt itself limits lateral movement of the elements by the shank of the bolt bearing upon the sides of the holes in the clamped elements. Such joints require less clamping force, because a high level of friction between the clamped surfaces is not required. The clearance between the bolt and the holes means that some lateral movement may occur before the bolt bears against the sides of the holes.

Even when designed as a bearing joint, the surface friction between the clamped elements may be sufficient to resist movement for some time, especially when the building may not yet be fully loaded ' thus it operates initially as a friction joint. When the lateral force becomes sufficient to overcome this friction, the clamped elements move until the sides of the holes bear against the shank of the bolt. This movement ' "slip into bearing" ' usually starts and stops very suddenly, often releasing elastic energy in the associated elements, resulting in a loud but harmless bang.[18]

International standards

[

edit

]

• SA-193/SA-193M: "Specification for alloy-steel and stainless steel bolting materials for high-temperature service"
• SA-194/SA-194M: "Specification for carbon and alloy steel nuts for bolts for high-temperature service"
• SA-320/SA-320M: "Specification for alloy steel bolting materials for low-temperature service"
• EN : "Flanges and their joints - Bolting"
  • EN -1: "Flanges and their joints - Bolting - Part 1: Selection of bolting"
  • EN -2: "Flanges and their joints ' Bolting ' Part 2: Classification of bolt materials for steel flanges, PN designated"
  • EN -2: "Flanges and their joints ' Bolting ' Part 3: Classification of bolt materials for steel flanges, class designated"
• ISO : "Hexagon head bolts - Product grades A and B"
• ISO : "Hexagon head screws - Product grades A and B"
• ISO : "Hexagon nuts, style 1 - Product grades A and B"
• ISO : "Hexagon nuts, style 2 - Product grades A and B"

See also

[

edit

]

References

[

edit

]

Notes

Bibliography

Belleville washers

Belleville washers

trudels

(Mechanical)

(OP)

9 Sep 11 15:38

Hi guys,

I need an info on Belleville washers. I want to know what is the max number of times a single belleville washer can be used/reused. I want to know this because the mechanics where I work were once told to only use the same washer twice. We have a LOT of washers here and I wonder if they could use them more than 2 times.

Thanks a lot for your time,

Simon
 

Replies continue below

Recommended for you

RE: Belleville washers

Tmoose

(Mechanical)

9 Sep 11 15:52

sounds like a question for the manufacturer about specific part numbers.  

then there may be a problem of keeping track of how many time they have been re-used

RE: Belleville washers

JohnRBaker

(Mechanical)

9 Sep 11 16:05

Based on this impression, it would appear that this is an issue which the manufactures are talking about without really being prompted to do and as such it suggests a couple of things. 1) it feels as if there has been problems in the past, which could very well explain why your mechanics warned you about this, but 2) it would also appear that the manufactures may have responded to this by producing better products and backing them up with test data.  I would say that

Tmoose

might have the right idea, check with the manufacture of the washers that you're using and see what they have to say about the fatigue life of their particular products.  

I just did a simple Google search and turned up many instances where the manufactures of Belleville Washers go out of their way to promote the idea that they have done extensive fatigue testing and they assure the buyer that their products are resistant to fatigue failure.Based on this impression, it would appear that this is an issue which the manufactures are talking about without really being prompted to do and as such it suggests a couple of things. 1) it feels as if there has been problems in the past, which could very well explain why your mechanics warned you about this, but 2) it would also appear that the manufactures may have responded to this by producing better products and backing them up with test data. I would say thatmight have the right idea, check with the manufacture of the washers that you're using and see what they have to say about the fatigue life of their particular products.

John R. Baker, P.E.
Product 'Evangelist'
Product Design Solutions
Siemens PLM Software Inc.
Industry Sector
Cypress, CA
http://www.siemens.com/plm
UG/NX Museum:   http://www.plmworld.org/p/cm/ld/fid=209

To an Engineer, the glass is twice as big as it needs to be.
 

RE: Belleville washers

rb

(Aerospace)

9 Sep 11 16:07

it'd depend on whether the washer has been deformed ... no?

RE: Belleville washers

desertfox

(Mechanical)

9 Sep 11 16:12

This site has an FAQ asking you're question.

http://www.bellevillesprings.com/disc-springs-faqs.html

Regards

desertfox

Hi trudelsThis site has an FAQ asking you're question.Regardsdesertfox

RE: Belleville washers

trudels

(Mechanical)

(OP)

9 Sep 11 16:17

Thanks a lot guys for your answers, I will contact my supplier to have more info!

Thank again

RE: Belleville washers

Cockroach

(Mechanical)

10 Sep 11 12:42

Do the research and ensure the Belleville Washer application suits the components needed.

There are a tremendous amount of computational engines for stress analysis on the web. Your issue is one of cyclic loading and lifetime. You can definitely re-use a Belleville Washer stack more than twice, depending on your application. In my experience, rare to use them only twice, probably a mis-spec of the application. They are way more reliable than that!Do the research and ensure the Belleville Washer application suits the components needed.

Kenneth J Hueston, PEng
Principal
Sturni-Hueston Engineering Inc
Edmonton, Alberta Canada

RE: Belleville washers

unclesyd

(Materials)

10 Sep 11 13:29

If you want to educate yourself on the application and design of disk spring components here is a link to the Schnoor handbook.

Key Bellevilles has a CD for the design and application of disk springs
 
http://schnorr.com/docs/Handbook.pdf

I would definately follow the advice posted above about contacting you spring manufacturer for information on the specific characteristics of your spring as there are numerous designs for different applications.If you want to educate yourself on the application and design of disk spring components here is a link to the Schnoor handbook.Key Bellevilles has a CD for the design and application of disk springs

RE: Belleville washers

drawoh

(Mechanical)

10 Sep 11 16:38

   Roark's Equations has a section explaining Belleville washers.  You can work out the stress for yourself, and analyse for fatigue.  They are springs.  They are under a lot of stress.

trudels,Roark's Equations has a section explaining Belleville washers. You can work out the stress for yourself, and analyse for fatigue. They are springs. They are under a lot of stress.

               JHG

RE: Belleville washers

Grindy

(Industrial)

10 Sep 11 17:54

I used to work with machine tools and they are often used to securely hold tools in place. These tools could be subjected to 'tool changes' many hundreds of times per shift. This would constantly be putting the washers under stress/fatigue. In seven years I didn't have to replace a single one.

That said I have seen failures with them in my current job, but they are subjected to far greater forces (400 Tonne presses) and in a harsh environment (concrete products).

RE: Belleville washers

fastline12

(Aerospace)

11 Sep 11 14:10

Agree with Grindy.  We own many CNC machines and have rebuilt many draw bar systems that retain a machine tool holder in the spindle.  It is very common to get approx 100,000 tool changes without issue.  They are usually compounded in series and parallel to achieve a target amount of travel and force.  They are usually compressed to max every time, then released BUT they are usually at about 20-40% of compression when released so they retain a draw force on the tool when running in the spindle.  

IMO, you can get a lot of cycles from them.  IMO, the nasty vibrations and harmonics from machining largely contributes to the failure of the washers, not just the fatigue limits.   

RE: Belleville washers

rmw

(Mechanical)

11 Sep 11 18:40

I know of a product where belleville washers are used as spring packs for actuators where the actuator can and often does drive into the spring pack when subjected to high operating torque.  The flexure of the spring pack allows the mechanism to flex so that a torque switch can be made (or broken) when the flexure exceeds a preset value.

These washers flex to some extent every time the actuator operates if it is operating at or near its rated torque and only flex to the maximum extent so as to trip the torque switch if the design torque value is exceeded.

These belleville washers certainly are "reused" time and time again without ever being disassembled.

rmw

RE: Belleville washers

dgallup

(Automotive)

12 Sep 11 18:10

My Honda VF750F uses a belleville washer to clamp the clutch pack. Still working fine after 28 years.

The Help for this program was created in Windows Help format, which depends on a feature that isn't included in this version of Windows.
 

RE: Belleville washers

looslib

(Mechanical)

13 Sep 11 10:28
 

A lot depends on your type of application and requirement for reliability. In race cars, teams typically use new parts everytime they rebuild the car between races. Might be excesssive and waste some good parts, but they can't afford any chances. Nuts, bolts and washers are the most common parts that are not reused.

"Wildfires are dangerous, hard to control, and economically catastrophic."

Ben Loosli

RE: Belleville washers

MiketheEngineer

(Structural)

13 Sep 11 12:10

Tend to agree with looslib...

The mfg will probably say change them every time - since they are in the business of "selling" them.

For non-critical apps - I am sure they can be re-used.  But if you are building space shuttles or holding jet engines on airplanes or building race cars - I think I would use new ones every time.

RE: Belleville washers

Tmoose

(Mechanical)

13 Sep 11 17:04

Sometimes NEW = Never Ever Worked (before), especially in this age of components from suppliers from far away.  Not that it was all good in the good old days, or sometimes they make 'em much better than they used to, but..............

Some moderately strict MIL spex allow reusing nylon locking nuts multiple times, or until the prevailing torque drops below some nominal value.

Some Bellevilles are designed so as to not exceed their yield strength when squashed completely flat, so would be hard to damage in that regard by tightening very hard.

RE: Belleville washers

israelkk

(Aerospace)

14 Sep 11 04:26

I am watching this post for sometime and without dis-respect I am disappointed with the shallow discussion regarding Belleville spring selection and design. No one even mentioned that the theory and closed form design and analysis formulations or Belleville springs (cone disc springs) are well known for decades. Every engineering graduate student should be able to use those formulas to design a new spring and to check how an existing of off the shelf spring will fit the design goals.

When a Belleville spring is compressed to flat or even beyond flat, three types of stresses are usually needed to be taken into account. One is a compressive strength at the top inside diameter of the spring and the other two are tensile strength (one at the bottom large outside diameter and one at the top inside diameter of the disc). Therefore, for cyclic operation only the tensile stresses should be taken into account. However, most if not all Belleville spring manufacturing processes include a preset (scraging or set remove as it is sometimes called) process as that last process that induces favorable residual compressive stresses at the points where tensile stress governs the design. Therefore, much higher loads are able from such a spring compared to a spring that didn't include a preset process in it's manufacturing process.

RE: Belleville washers

drawoh

(Mechanical)

14 Sep 11 11:48

   I set up a spreadsheet using the Belleville spring equations from Roark's, and some similar equations from the SAE spring handbook.  I wanted to design my own Belleville springs.  As a sanity check, I pulled out my

   Your preset would increase the maximum stress a bit, but the Schnorr washers can be compressed flat, according to my calculations.  Couldn't you just punch them out of (fairly) soft metal and then heat treat them?

   I wound up designing some delrin lens preloaders, and I left strict instructions to not compress them flat.  

israelkk,I set up a spreadsheet using the Belleville spring equations from Roark's, and some similar equations from the SAE spring handbook. I wanted to design my own Belleville springs. As a sanity check, I pulled out my Schnorr catalogue, and I punched in their values. My spreadsheet and Schnorr were in fairly close agreement. I was happy.Your preset would increase the maximum stress a bit, but the Schnorr washers can be compressed flat, according to my calculations. Couldn't you just punch them out of (fairly) soft metal and then heat treat them?I wound up designing some delrin lens preloaders, and I left strict instructions tocompress them flat.

               JHG

RE: Belleville washers

rmw

(Mechanical)

14 Sep 11 21:33

Nice tutorial for our shallow minds israelKK, He now knows the theory behind how they are made, but you didn't answer the OP's question - how many times can he reuse his belleville washer?

rmw

RE: Belleville washers

israelkk

(Aerospace)

15 Sep 11 01:08

rmw

Knowing the formulations, the loads and deflections on a spring, a competent designer can easily calculate/estimate the stresses and the fatigue life. To answer a question, preliminary specific data is needed including the spring dimensions, loads and deflections. The fact that none of this is given by trudels and your post proves my point.  

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members! Already a Member? Login

News

For more flange bolt washerinformation, please contact us. We will provide professional answers.